Ghajini vs Ghajini

Ghajini is just like the IPL. The film is a money minting machine and has more than lived up to its hype and expectation. Well not exactly if you would analyse Ghajini from a neutral perspective. The film is good and bad. It is good in terms of delivering riveting entertainment for a good measure of three hours. It has grossed Rs. 140 crores within 10 days of release, something Bollywood has never witnessed in the past. It is bad in the sense that it’s a faithful reproduction of the Tamil version and a little bit of improvisation and improvement here and there would not have gone unnoticed by viewers. My attempt is not to write a review of this movie or criticize the movie. But do not blame me if I end up doing just that. Having watched both the Tamil and Hindi versions, I will try to do a fair and unbiased comparison of both versions.
I was stunned by the fact that except for the last twenty minutes of the movie, the movie is a frame by frame replica of the tamil version. The logical flaws and loopholes that existed in the original continue to plague the hindi version. For example, how on earth did Sanjay Singhania (Aamir) tattoo all the important details on his body remains mystery? If he forgets everything after fifteen minutes, how did he first comeup with a list of people to be killed. I understand that sometimes we need to condone such flaws since no movie can be perfect. Ghajini’s first half is breezy and fun to watch. It has a feel good factor thanks to Asin’s bundle of youthful energy and enthusiasm. She is lovely to watch and has excellent screen presence and always flashing a gorgeous smile full of energy. Sadly the same cannot be said Aamir. Aamir has focused all his attention on action scenes that one gets the feeling that he felt a little bored doing the romantic scenes. Surya had played the romantic role to perfection in Tamil and this is where Aamir slips behind. Surya thanks to his age looked young, handsome and a perfect match to Asin. Aamir looks a little old for the romantic scenes. His body looks like that of a 25 year old. He flaunts a perfectly toned 8 Packs body which is the result of months and months of hard work and dedication. Unfortunately except for in the Behka song, he looks a bit old and uncomfortable doing the romantic scenes with Asin.
Now coming to the supporting cast, Tinu Anand does a good job as the Ad company owner exhibiting subtleness in his acting. Riaz Khan is wasted as he was in Tamil. Pradeep Rawat as Ghajini is impressive and genuinely invokes fear. So much so that I started hating his mannerisms: the trademarks of a genuine villain. Just like Nayanthara in the tamil version, Jiah Khan looks totally out of place in her role as a medical student. Didn’t Murugadoss find any other girl? Oh my god, she managed with her liberal skin show in Nishabd, but sadly this is no nishabd. This role has good potential for acting and sadly she has let it flow down the drain. She is just 20 and it’s still not too late to switch careers. Acting? No No!

Coming to the music, A.R. Rahman once again creates magic with his music and all the songs are good. Whether they are a match to the astounding tracks composed by Harris Jeyaraj or not, only time will tell. Since this is my independent opinion, I will stick my neck out and say that Harris triumphs. Though the songs by A.R. Rahman are good, the background music of Ghajini lacks emotional attachment and feel. The BGMs by Harris were poignant and colorful depending on the situation. As far as the BGMs are concerned, there is no comparison here and Harris wins hands down.
The climax of the film is where both movies differ considerably. Thankfully there is no double action of Pradeep Rawat. If the tamil climax was gory thanks to the villain’s heinous acts, the hindi version is brutal courtesy Aamir. There is a lot of iron smashing in the climax and this film deserves an ‘A’ certificate for the violence alone. All in all it’s a very good masala movie aimed at providing three hours of edge of the seat entertainment and the audience response indicates that Murugadoss, Aamir and their team have succeeded in giving the audience more than what was expected from this Mega project. Paisa vasool!
2 comments:
hey Aj, great post... I like the way you have written a critic of the movie. I saw the Hindi movie Ghajini on the first day of release. I am not sure if you have seen the movie in a theater. if you have not, i suggest you do! I thought it was better than the tamil version because of a slick climax. I am sure it was Aamir's idea to change the climax dramatically. And I do not agree that Aamir has not played the lover boy's role well. There were some visible creases of age on his face but other than that he was awesome in the entire movie. Asin has also done a great job.
Hey btw way u r doing a great job with this blog da.. good post.
@Bka, Thanks da for comments...I do agree that the climax was slick and better than the tamil version but other than that there werent any major improvements to the movie. With Aamir around, you expect some improvements and plugging of loopholes. Sadly its been missed. The tamil version was riddled with flaws and the fact that no attempt has been made to correct them is what irks me. On the whole, a good enterntaining movie.
Post a Comment